35 min

Building a Repeatable Creative Studio: How Birdhill Delivers Monthly CPG Photography at Scale

Josh Carn-Saferstein, founder of Birdhill Studio, shares how he built a specialized monthly photography and stop-motion studio for CPG brands starting from a third bedroom during COVID. He breaks down the systems, software milestones, and focused service model that allow his small Denver team to deliver consistent, high-quality creative without scope creep. The conversation also covers buying out his co-founder, navigating AI in a craft-driven business, and the philosophy of 'falling forward' as an entrepreneur.

creative operationscpg marketingentrepreneurshipproductized servicesai in creative

Guest

Josh Carn-Saferstein

Founder, Birdhill Studio

Josh Carn-Saferstein is the owner-operator of Birdhill Studio, a Denver-based creative studio that produces photo and stop-motion video content for CPG brands on a monthly retainer basis. He founded the company in 2020 while finishing college at the University of Michigan, driven by a systems-oriented mindset and a belief that brands needed a consistent, specialized content partner rather than one-off production shoots. Since buying out his co-founder in 2022, Josh has grown the studio into a fully in-house operation with a dedicated studio space and a tightly defined service model.

Key Takeaways

  • 1.Radical specialization — offering only photography and stop-motion on a monthly retainer — lets Birdhill build repeatable systems and deliver consistent quality without scope creep.
  • 2.A 19-milestone project management workflow ensures every shoot, from concept approval to model sourcing to Instacart produce delivery, runs on autopilot without constant team communication.
  • 3.Pricing and deliverables listed publicly on the website intentionally constrain the service offering, which in turn makes the entire production process more automatable and predictable.
  • 4.AI is used sparingly at Birdhill — primarily for internal drafting and image refinement — because brand authenticity and real photography are core to what clients pay for.
  • 5.Buying out a co-founder can be the 'happiest divorce' when both partners communicate honestly about their evolving goals and structure the transition with a clear wind-down period.

Full Transcript

0:20
Josh Carn-Saferstein

I'm Josh, based in Denver, Colorado, and I'm owner-operator at Birdhill Studio. We create photo and stop-motion video content for CPG brands on a monthly basis — started in 2020, right around COVID.

0:58
Josh Carn-Saferstein

My brain works in a very systems-oriented way, so from the start the question was: how can we make this repeatable rather than doing one photo shoot for a client and then wondering where the next one is coming from?

1:39
Josh Carn-Saferstein

Doing one photo shoot a year is tough to stretch across an entire year with product launches, seasonal campaigns, and all the different channels brands are pushing on digitally. We came in to solve that — fresh creative delivered consistently without brands having to build their own production house.

2:32
Macgill Davis

Can you talk about the big inflection points as the business has evolved — especially recently with AI, but even before that?

3:10
Josh Carn-Saferstein

The very first inflection point was simply: can we make enough monthly revenue to keep the lights on? Once we hit that goal, we could trust the model worked and start building on it.

6:43
Josh Carn-Saferstein

At the end of 2022 I bought my business partner Troy out — I call it the happiest divorce, because we both shared what we wanted and there was no disagreement. He told me he didn't want to own a business anymore, and I was honestly taken aback because I expected pushback.

7:41
Josh Carn-Saferstein

In 2024 I planted my flag and said we are going all in-studio, because this business functions better when people can just talk rather than jumping on endless Zoom calls. In October 2024 we opened a dedicated studio space in Denver.

8:49
Josh Carn-Saferstein

For every photo shoot we have 19 different milestones that have to happen — from reviewing concepts with the client to ensuring props arrive on time, sourcing a model, and making sure Instacart produce arrives the day of. Without the software systems we've built, I believe we would be drowning.

10:04
Macgill Davis

What would you say is your real differentiator as a business? I noticed you were very clear when you introduced the company about exactly who it's for.

10:42
Josh Carn-Saferstein

We are extremely focused and specialized — we don't do projects, one-off shoots, paid ads, social management, or graphic design. It's not that doing less is special in itself; it's that we've put all of our resources around one specific service and we speak very honestly about what we do and don't do.

11:42
Josh Carn-Saferstein

A small example: when we're creating monthly deliverables, an asset will often live in more than one place — so if it's going to be a website banner and an Instagram story ad, we're shooting it in a way that allows for cropability on both. That level of detail is only possible because we're not spread across a dozen other services.

14:34
Josh Carn-Saferstein

What you sell is what you're going to get operationally. Because we have clearly defined plans with exact pricing and deliverables listed on our website, we're intentionally constraining ourselves — and that's what makes the downstream processes repeatable and automatable.

19:40
Josh Carn-Saferstein

Entrepreneurship can feel lonely, but it also felt lonely with a partner because things were still extremely challenging. Since the buyout it feels more aligned — there's no confusion about who does what or who makes the call.

24:16
Macgill Davis

I'm curious about the meta-process: how do you decide what to automate, how do you review it, and how has AI changed that thinking?

25:22
Josh Carn-Saferstein

Since we deliver on a monthly cycle, I think about how everything can flow back to phase one — month after month, across multiple clients, with photographer, stylist, producer, and retoucher all involved. The question is always: what is continuous rather than a one-off instance, and how can clicking one button trigger the next person's task automatically?

26:55
Josh Carn-Saferstein

A friend of mine described AI as ketchup — you can use a little of it in image creation and refinement, but if you try to build the whole meal around ketchup, it's not going to go well. I've mentally adopted that, because what brands come to us for is real, high-quality, consistent photography that tells their brand story with authenticity.

28:46
Josh Carn-Saferstein

We're delivering somewhere between 12 and 25 images a month per brand, so each concept has to pull its weight — there are no throwaway assets. That's why we're diligent about not just leaning into whatever makes something go quicker.

34:42
Josh Carn-Saferstein

A phrase I believe in for our team is 'falling forward' — as long as our momentum feels like we're learning and growing, the rest is okay if it's not perfect. I'd much rather be falling forward than backward.

Frequently Asked Questions

Birdhill Studio creates photo and stop-motion video content exclusively for CPG brands on a monthly retainer basis. They do not run social accounts, paid ads, or graphic design — they focus entirely on producing the visual assets that feed into those channels, delivering between 12 and 25 images per brand per month.

Every shoot follows a 19-milestone workflow built into their project management software, covering everything from client concept review to prop sourcing, model payments, and produce delivery. Automations trigger the next team member when a task is complete, so the team wakes up knowing exactly what to do without relying on constant back-and-forth communication.

Josh describes AI as 'ketchup' — useful in small doses for image refinement or internal drafting, but not something to build the whole meal around. Because clients rely on Birdhill for authentic brand storytelling through real photography, leaning too heavily on AI-generated imagery risks eroding the trust and brand integrity that clients pay for.

Josh describes the buyout as the 'happiest divorce' because both he and his co-founder Troy were honest about what they wanted — Troy ultimately wanted out entirely, which surprised Josh but made the transition smooth. He credits the outcome to a 60/40 ownership structure that gave Josh final say from the start, and to a culture of radical honesty between the two partners throughout the eight-month wind-down.

Josh believes that what you sell is what you get operationally — publishing clear, fixed plans eliminates custom RFP work and forces the business to constrain its offering, which in turn makes every downstream process more repeatable and automatable. It also filters out brands that need a broader agency relationship, ensuring Birdhill only works with clients who are a genuine fit.

Join hundreds of thousands of people who made Rize a core part of how they work.